Archie Yates Max Mercer Ellie Kemper Pam McKenzie Rob Delaney Jeff McKenzie Aisling Bea Carol Mercer Pete Holmes Uncle Blake Kenan Thompson Gavin Washington Timothy Simons Hunter Ally Maki Mei Chris Parnell Uncle Stu Devin Ratray Buzz McCallister Max Ivutin Chris McKenzie Andrew Daly Mike Mercer Maddie Holliday Katie Mercer Mikey Day Priest Esther Povitsky Daisy Breckin Marty Adams Annoying Passenger Jim Rash Bell Choir Leader Catherine Cohen Mrs. Claus Amy Okuda Ticketing Agent Bronwen Mantel Barbara Tristan D. Lalla Orderly Gayle Garfinkle Old Lady Coven Hazel Gorin Old Lady Coven