Sarah Paulson Mother / Diane Kiera Allen Daughter / Chloe Pat Healy Mailman Sara Sohn Nurse Erik Athavale Doctor B. J. Harrison Meeting Leader Sharon Bajer Pharmacist Onalee Ames Crying Hands Bradley Sawatzky Obstetrician Cory Wojcik Person in Line Tony Revolori Brooklyn Boy Steve Pacaud Doctor (uncredited) Derek James Trapp Nurse (uncredited)