B. J. Novak Ben Manalowitz Boyd Holbrook Ty Shaw J. Smith-Cameron Sharon Shaw Issa Rae Eloise Ashton Kutcher Quentin Sellers Lio Tipton Abilene Shaw Dove Cameron Kansas City Shaw Isabella Amara Paris Shaw Eli Bickel El Stupido Shaw John Mayer John Louanne Stephens Granny Carole Shaw Zach Villa Sancholo Clint Obenchain Crawl Ben Whitehair Officer Dan Grayson Berry Officer Mike Nathaniel Augustson Rowdy Stranger #1 Sean J. Dillingham Rowdy Stranger Tracy S. Lee Radio Intern Micah McNeil Texas Tech Fan Sarah Minnich J. Nathan Simmons Diner Patron Crystal Mayes Bar Patron / Rodeo Fan (uncredited) Gonzalo Robles Not Sancholo (uncredited)