Sienna Miller Deb Callahan Christina Hendricks Kath Aaron Paul Chris Will Sasso Terry Sky Ferreira Bridget Callahan Pat Healy Ray Alex Neustaedter Tyler Hanrick E. Roger Mitchell Det. Sergeant Morris Kentucker Audley Brett Tobeck Aidan McGraw Jesse (Age 7) Aidan Fiske Jesse (Age 13) Amy Madigan Peggy Kelly Rose Golden Jenna Cunningham Bates Wilder Detective O'Brien Maggie Castle Brett's Wife Maggie Budzyna Colleen Rebecca Gibel Nursing Assistant #1 Rachel Singer Mrs. Derrick Danielle Lyons Search Party Volunteer (uncredited) Michael Marchand Police Officer (uncredited)