Adam Driver Charlie Barber Scarlett Johansson Nicole Barber Laura Dern Nora Fanshaw Alan Alda Bert Spitz Ray Liotta Jay Marotta Julie Hagerty Sandra Merritt Wever Cassie Azhy Robertson Henry Barber Wallace Shawn Frank Martha Kelly The Evaluator Mark O'Brien Carter Mitchum Julia Greer Street Solicitor #1 Matthew Maher Theater Actor Mickey Sumner Beth - Theater Actor Jasmine Cephas Jones Theater Actor Gideon Glick Theater Actor Motell Gyn Foster Theater Actor David Turner Theater Actor Raymond J. Lee Theater Actor Mary Wiseman Theater Actor Irene Choi Theater Actor Matthew Shear Terry - Theater Actor Brooke Bloom Mary Ann Annie Hamilton Becca - Nora's Assistant