Brandon Flynn Max Ki Hong Lee Dan Annie Mumolo Jan Peter Scolari Paul Priscilla Lopez Esther Susan James Berger Rosemary Monique Kim Yu Shen Lindsay Mushett Dan's date Tom Proctor Vin Mick O'Rourke Blind Man Jude Washock Movie Patron/Valencia's Friend Tiffany Milian Erica Natalie Paige Goldberg Nurse Anthony Traina Wombat Tim Simon Waiter